Highlight
This rich blend of deviled eggs with macaroni results in a smooth, zesty pasta dish that turns ordinary into extraordinary. Every bite brings the familiar comfort of basic macaroni salad kicked up with the smooth, creamy goodness of well-prepared deviled eggs.
I came up with this dish after an Easter Sunday when we had tons of eggs left. When friends tried it, their faces lit up - I knew right away this wasn't your run-of-the-mill pasta salad but something truly special.
Choosing Top-notch Components
- Elbow macaroni: Go for sturdy pasta that won't get mushy
- Fresh eggs: Local eggs give you richer, more colorful yolks
- Greek yogurt and mayonnaise: The combo makes just the right creaminess
- Dijon mustard: Brings a fancy zip and richness
- Red onion and celery: Adds that must-have crunch
- Fresh chives: Lifts the whole dish with freshness
Building Your Showstopper
- Nailing the Pasta:
- Get water bubbling with plenty of salt. Cook pasta until just firm. Cool right away under cold water. Let it sit until completely cool.
- Handling the Eggs:
- Cook eggs until they're just right. Drop in ice water for easier shells. Pull out yolks carefully. Cut whites into even pieces.
- Whipping Up Dressing:
- Squish yolks until they're silky. Mix with your creamy stuff. Add salt and pepper to taste. Thin out if it's too thick.
- Putting It All Together:
- Toss pasta with chopped egg whites. Gently mix in your dressing. Sprinkle in your crunchy veggies. Let it chill thoroughly.
Highlight
My grandma always added a tiny bit of sugar to her deviled egg mix to cut the tang - it's amazing what it does for this salad too.
Tasty Companions
This goes great with anything off the grill for backyard parties, or pack it for a fancy outdoor lunch. It's always a hit at group dinners and fits right in at summer cookouts.
Fun Twists
Jazz it up with crispy bacon bits, chunks of avocado, or sweet roasted peppers. Try a Greek-style version with olives and crumbled feta, or give it some kick with a splash of hot sauce in the mix.
Staying Delicious
Keep it in a covered bowl in your fridge for up to three days. Add a splash of fresh dressing before serving if it looks dry. Don't try freezing it - the texture won't survive.
This deviled egg mac salad has become my go-to dish that everyone asks for. It shows how sometimes the most requested recipes come from simple leftovers and a bit of kitchen playtime.
Highlight
Recipe FAQs
- → Can it be prepped early?
- Absolutely! Chill it for up to a day—the flavors get even better as it sits.
- → How long does it stay fresh?
- Seal it tight and refrigerate. It’ll keep up to 3-4 days.
- → What other pasta can I use?
- Totally fine! Try small shapes like shells, bow ties, or rotini.
- → Can it be lightened up?
- Yes! Sub mayo with just Greek yogurt, and choose whole grain pasta.
- → Why rinse the pasta cold?
- It cools it down fast and stops it from softening too much.