Cozy German Potato Salad

Nothing disappears faster at my house than this old-school German potato salad. The potatoes just soak up all that sweet-tangy sauce made in the bacon fat, and honestly, it's impossible to resist those crunchy bacon pieces on top. Serving it right out of the pan always reminds me of cozy family get-togethers and potlucks. Warm and nostalgic—can't beat it.

When I whipped this up the first time, the irresistible combo of vinegar and crispy bacon brought my husband running before I even finished. It's now a go-to at our BBQs and holiday spreads.

Tasty Ingredients

• Flat-leaf parsley or chives Adds a fresh, bright twist sprinkled over just before digging in. Snip them at the last minute for the best flavor punch.
• Olive oil Ties everything together with shine and a hint of fruitiness. Only extra virgin with good color and aroma, please.
• Salt and black pepper Freshly ground pepper really makes a difference. Don’t skip on seasoning—it makes all the flavors pop.
• Sugar A pinch is all you need to balance out the sharp bits. Fine sugar melts into the sauce best.
• Dijon mustard Brings a little zing and layers of flavor. The smooth European version is what you want, not yellow squeeze stuff.
• Distilled white vinegar That classic pickle-y bite is the secret here. Use clear vinegar, nothing funky-smelling.
• Chicken broth Lets the potatoes soak up extra flavor and makes the whole mix creamy. Low-salt is great if you want to watch the salt level.
• Garlic Only whole cloves for big taste—skip the jarred stuff. Choose ones that are firm and not sprouting.
• Sweet onion Chopped up fine for a gentle crunch and subtle sweetness. Only fresh, no mushy onions here.
• Bacon Grab nice thick strips with some fat—flavor matters since it runs through the whole dish.
• Red potatoes They hang onto their shape and soak up all the sauce. Go for smaller, smooth-skinned ones if you can.

Simple Step-by-Step

Finish and Serve:

Spoon everything onto your plate. Lay those crispy bacon bits on top, then toss on a bunch of fresh chives or parsley. Enjoy it warm for full flavor and cozy vibes.

Combine and Toss:

Mix the cubed potatoes into your pan of warm dressing, splash in that olive oil, and gently fold so the potatoes get covered in the glossy sauce. Taste and tweak the seasoning as needed.

Build the Dressing:

In the same pan, pour in broth and vinegar with the cooked onions and garlic. Add Dijon, sugar, salt, and pepper. Whisk and scrape the pan to pick up all that goodness. Let it bubble, then simmer for about five minutes so it thickens up and reduces.

Peel and Cut Potatoes:

Once those spuds aren’t too hot, peel off the skins and chop into cubes, aiming for about a half-inch each—not too big, not too small.

Crisp the Bacon and Sauté Aromatics:

Fry the bacon pieces in a skillet until super crisp and golden, about seven or eight minutes. Pull out the bacon and keep the fat in the pan. Toss in onions and let them get soft but not brown, about two minutes, then add garlic for just thirty seconds till it smells awesome.

Prepare the Potatoes:

Fill a big pot with your potatoes, cover them in cool water, and bring to a low boil. Let them go for fifteen to twenty minutes, just until they're easy to poke with a fork. Drain and let them cool on a tray at least ten minutes—it makes them easier to chop later.

Pin

The bacon is hands down my favorite piece. It always makes me think of my grandma—she was convinced bacon took everything to the next level. One Easter, we cracked up when someone tried to steal extra bacon bits and she caught them just by smelling it cooking.

Storing Leftovers

Stash any extras in a lidded container in the fridge—they’re best within three days. To warm it up, toss some broth or olive oil in a skillet and heat gently so the potatoes stay soft and don’t dry out.

Changing Up Ingredients

No red potatoes handy? Yukon Golds do the trick for creamy texture. Going meatless? Skip the bacon, use butter, add smoky paprika for flavor. Want a fruitier punch? Apple cider vinegar is great—just know it'll taste a bit different.

How to Serve It

This goes amazingly with grilled bratwurst, juicy chicken, or roast turkey. It works for potlucks or lunchboxes since it’s delish at room temp but it’s at its very best right after making it warm.

Story Behind It

This warm, tangy dish comes from southern Germany. Instead of mayo, you get a bacon vinaigrette—that’s the Bavarian way. Every area puts its own twist on it, but bacon and tart dressing are the tradition. It always shows up at festive tables as a way to make guests feel right at home.

Recipe Questions & Answers

→ Which potatoes hold up best?

Totally go for red or yellow waxy types—they don’t fall apart when you toss everything together.

→ Why bother with plain white vinegar?

That classic super-sharp flavor you expect in this kind of salad? It’s thanks to plain white vinegar—don’t skip it.

→ How do I stop it from turning into mush?

Let the potatoes cool a bit so they can soak up the sauce but stay together. Also, try not to overboil them.

→ Can I prep this dish in advance?

For sure—make it early, then warm it up gently and stir in a dash more oil or broth to get things glossy again.

→ Do I have to peel the potatoes?

If you want them silky, peel them up. But leaving skins on keeps more bold flavor and nutrition, so it’s your call.

→ Best tip for super crispy bacon?

Just fry bacon on a steady medium heat until it’s nice and crunchy, then crumble it right over the top.