Pin it
Juicy green peas, tangy cheddar cheese, and crisp veggies blend together in this amazingly easy salad. The homemade sauce coats everything in a smooth, rich layer, making a dish that's both familiar and fresh. Great for summer get-togethers but flexible enough to enjoy all year long, this no-cook treat goes well with anything from barbecued meats to holiday dinners while taking almost no effort and giving tons of taste.
I found this treasure while looking through my grandma's hand-written recipe box last year. The paper had stains and was clearly well-used, which showed it must've been a hit. When I brought it to our Memorial Day cookout, my uncle took one taste and right away said, "This tastes just like the salad Grandma always made!" Seeing his face light up with those food memories made this simple dish feel really special.
Tasty Ingredients
Colorful Base
- Green Peas: Tiny sweet balls that bring natural sugar and a soft pop when you bite them. Fresh ones work great in season, but frozen peas thawed in cool water keep their bright look and feel perfectly any time of year.
- Celery: Gives needed snap and a light peppery freshness that works against the soft peas. Pick firm stalks and cut them thin for the right crunch throughout the salad.
- Radishes: These spicy little gems add surprising kick and lovely color contrast. Cut them super thin to spread their bold flavor without taking over the other ingredients.
Tasty Extras
- Cheddar Cheese: Tiny chunks of sharp cheddar give spots of rich flavor all through the salad. Freshly cut cheese works better than pre-shredded stuff for better taste and the right chewy feel.
- Hard-Boiled Eggs: Add creaminess and protein while bringing another texture layer. Cook them just until the yolks set but stay bright yellow for the best look and taste.
- Green Onions: Give mild onion flavor without the strength of regular onions. Using both white and green parts adds more complex taste and looks nice in the finished dish.
Sauce Mix
- Mayonnaise: Makes the creamy base that wraps each ingredient perfectly. Regular full-fat kinds give the best flavor and texture, though lighter ones work okay if you prefer.
- Sweet Pickle Relish: Brings tangy sweetness and tiny bits of texture throughout the sauce. The light pickle flavor boosts everything it touches without taking over.
- Seasonings: A careful mix of sugar, seasoned salt, and ground mustard takes this simple sauce to another level, adding depth that might otherwise be missing.
Pin it
Easy Assembly
Veggie Prep
Start by making sure your peas are fully thawed if using frozen, draining off any extra water that might water down your sauce later. Pat them lightly with paper towels if needed to remove surface moisture while keeping their round shape intact.
Smart Cutting
Chop your celery into small, even pieces, trying for bits about the same size as the peas themselves. This careful sizing makes sure you get balanced bites with well-mixed textures and flavors throughout the finished salad.
Gentle Mixing
Get your hard-boiled eggs ready by cutting them into pieces a bit bigger than the peas, keeping some of the nice contrast between white and yellow. Cut green onions at an angle to make them look better in the finished dish.
Cheese Method
Cut your cheddar cheese into small cubes instead of shredding it, letting you find little pockets of cheesy goodness throughout the salad. This way works better than shredding, which can get lost in the sauce.
Neat Slicing
Clean your radishes and slice them super thin, using a mandoline if you have one. Their bright pink edges make beautiful color contrast while spreading their spicy flavor throughout the salad without making it too strong.
Sauce Making
In another bowl, mix together mayonnaise, sweet pickle relish, sugar, seasoned salt, and ground mustard until totally smooth. Taste it and adjust the seasonings if needed before moving on to make sure the flavor balance is just right.
Light Tossing
Pour your finished sauce over the veggie mixture, using a rubber spatula to gently fold everything together. This careful approach coats each ingredient evenly while keeping the different textures that make this salad so good.
Flavor Mixing
Put your finished salad in a serving bowl, cover it well, and chill for at least an hour before serving. This resting time lets flavors blend nicely while the sauce soaks into each part for a well-rounded final result.
Pin it
The first time I made this salad, I tried using leftover roasted peas from dinner the night before instead of the usual fresh or frozen ones. It was still yummy, but it totally changed how the dish turned out. The roasted peas added a surprising nutty flavor that my husband actually liked better, but my kids all voted for the classic version with its sweeter, pop-in-your-mouth feel. Now I sometimes make it both ways depending on who's coming over for dinner.
Ideal Pairings
Turn this flexible salad into a full meal by serving it with grilled meats. The cool, creamy texture works great against hot chicken, juicy steaks, or flavorful salmon. The freshness cuts through rich foods, cleaning your palate between bites and making the whole meal better.
Make an old-fashioned picnic spread by matching this salad with fried chicken and soft biscuits. The combo creates a filling meal that feels both rich and wholesome. This works really well for outdoor gatherings where comfort food makes everyone feel relaxed.
Add this salad to holiday meals by serving it with sliced ham or turkey. The make-ahead ease cuts down on cooking stress while the light flavors balance heavier holiday foods. Many guests like having something fresh and bright on their plate among typically rich seasonal dishes.
Taste Twists
Try a Mediterranean spin by swapping feta for cheddar cheese and adding chopped cucumber and fresh dill to the mix. A splash of lemon juice in the sauce brightens everything while keeping the creamy character that makes this salad special. This version goes particularly well with grilled fish or chicken skewers.
Make the salad heartier by adding crispy bacon pieces and replacing some of the mayonnaise with sour cream for extra tang. The smoky, savory bacon goes great with the sweet peas while bringing another texture level. This version makes a fantastic side for burger cookouts or casual get-togethers.
Create a spring-themed version by mixing in chopped fresh asparagus and using small cubes of Swiss cheese instead of cheddar. A bit of Dijon mustard in the sauce complements these lighter flavors while keeping the creamy feel. This version fits perfectly at Easter gatherings or spring brunches.
Keeping Fresh
Keep it at its best by storing the salad in a flat airtight container instead of a deep bowl. This helps it cool faster throughout and stops condensation that might make the top layer watery. When stored right, the salad stays delicious for up to three days in the fridge.
Bring life back to day-old salad that seems a bit dry by gently mixing in a little extra mayonnaise just before serving. A teaspoon of cold water can help thin the sauce without weakening flavor if needed. This quick fix makes leftover salad taste almost as good as freshly made.
Use aging salad in new ways by spreading it in wrap sandwiches with sliced turkey or ham. The creamy texture works perfectly as a spread while the veggies add flavor and crunch. This smart reuse cuts down on food waste while making a completely different meal experience.
Pin it
I once took this salad to a block party where it sat next to fancy pasta dishes and complicated casseroles. Its simple look didn't grab much attention at first until someone tried it and quickly asked who made "that amazing pea thing." Soon, a small group gathered around my basic contribution, and I went home with an empty bowl and folks asking for the recipe. There's something really rewarding about watching people discover that everyday ingredients mixed thoughtfully can create outstanding flavors. This salad taught me that cooking doesn't always need to be complex to impress people—sometimes the magic happens when you just let simple ingredients do their thing.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I toss frozen peas into this dish?
- Totally, frozen peas are fine! Thaw them fully and dry them off to keep things fresh and not watery.
- → How early can I prep this mix?
- You can get started 24 hours before serving. It actually tastes better as the flavors settle in the fridge.
- → Is there a lighter option than mayo?
- Try mixing equal parts mayo and Greek yogurt. It still feels rich without being too heavy.
- → What dinners does this dish go with?
- This flexible mix works great with grilled meat, fried chicken, burgers, or sandwiches. Perfect for summertime gatherings.
- → How long will this stay fresh in the fridge?
- It'll stay good for about 3-4 days in a sealed container. Just know the veggies might lose some crunch over time.